In the realm of acoustics, sound diffusers play a pivotal role in shaping the quality and ambiance of audio spaces. We have delved deep into the working principles, mathematics, and practical applications of sound diffusers. This article aims to shed light on the intricate science behind sound diffusers, their types, dimensional performances, specific applications in live and mixing rooms, their limitations, and the potential pitfalls of attempting a DIY approach.
Working Principles and Mathematics of Sound Diffusers:
As the term suggests, sound diffusers are acoustic devices designed to "diffuse" sound waves. Depending upon the model of construction, diffusers are very powerful devices that can diffuse the soundwaves spatially and/ or temporally, thereby can be used for a variety of acoustic control measures ranging from as large as reducing standing waves to flutter echoes to simply adding a bit of liveliness in a room. Their working principles are based on the concepts of reflection, diffusion, and dispersion. When sound waves strike the surface of a sound diffuser, they are reflected and scattered in different directions, breaking up parallel sound paths and reducing potential acoustic issues.
The mathematics behind sound diffusers can be complex, involving concepts from wave theory, Fourier analysis, and diffraction theory. Manufacturers often use numerical simulations and computer modeling to optimize the design and performance of diffusers for specific applications. Discussing the exact physical mechanism of a diffuser in mathematical terms is out of the scope of this particular article, but we have already scheduled follow-up sequels to this series diving very deep into the world of diffusion. "With great power comes great responsibility" - If you are already excited about building a diffuser, keep this statement in mind, and by the end of this article, pretty much everything will fall in place for you to understand how destructive can these powerful devices be if not used correctly/wisely.
Types of Sound Diffusers:
Sound diffusers can be broadly categorized into three types: amplitude grating, phase grating, and diffracting diffusers.
1. Amplitude Grating Diffusers: These diffusers generally consist of alternating flat and curved surfaces that cause sound waves to be reflected in various directions due to the difference in surface height. They are theoretically effective in high-frequency sound diffusion.
Practically, as the name suggests, they work on the amplitude component of the soundwave and do not provide any observable temporal diffusion/alteration. Diffraction plays a major role in designing these kinds of diffusers.
2. Phase Grating Diffusers: Phase grating diffusers use a series of regularly spaced, reflective, or absorbing elements that cause phase cancellations and reinforce specific directions of sound diffusion. While these diffusers can be designed theoretically on any frequency in the human hearing range, they are feasible and more effective in the mid-frequency range. Being the most powerful diffuser models, phase grating diffusers allow a very accurate spatial and temporal dispersion if calculated and executed precisely, but equally, they pose a greater threat of introducing new acoustic problems (in contrast to other simpler types) if any small measure is overlooked!
3. Diffracting Devices: Diffraction can be basically understood as the phenomenon occurring when a soundwave interacts with a small object; where part of the soundwave where the wavelength is larger than the incident dimension of the object wraps around it without any temporal effects, the higher frequencies with wavelengths smaller than the object's incident dimensions are simply reflected back. These designs while do sound simple, need good attention to detail specifically on geometry and the crossover bands. The very narrow band of frequencies with wavelengths close to that of the object/slot dimensions do get temporally altered and attenuated but can be safely ignored if designs are based on precise calculations and perform as intended, but can destroy the entire acoustical environment if not. Poor decisions on geometry can result in accumulation at certain points, and generate resonance uncalculated!
Dimensional Performances of Diffusers:
Specific Applications of Diffusers include preserving natural room tone, adding liveliness, removing flutter echo from intended reflective surfaces, adding psychoacoustical cues, adding depth to a certain range of sound, creating an illusion of a different volume, etc.
Limitations and Problems with Diffusers:
Despite their benefits, sound diffusers have some limitations and potential problems:
1. Lobing Effects: Sound diffusers can cause lobing effects, where interference patterns result in uneven scattering and frequency response. More on that later!
2. Low-Frequency Reflection: To obtain effective diffusion, it is generally observed that you need them considerably large-sized. At least, for phase grating diffusers, you do! And that entire surface can behave like a simple plane reflective surface for frequencies below the design frequency. Troubleshooting this lies in correct placement, and also correctly designing the diffuser by carefully studying room size and room's limitations.
Now if you're thinking about diffusing sound to very low frequencies, you can't really get it functionally good with the parameters current tech is limited to. While there is a great name in the world who attempted low-frequency diffusion, there's also a reason why no one else tried repeating that in any manner. Temporally/spatially altering low-frequency sound is neither easy nor predictable, and in my personal opinion - no way sensible.
Why so? Stay tuned!
3. Morphing: Diffusers (Phase-grating) generally throw back amorphous sounds. While it is a lot of times the exact intention behind applying one, many DIYers do not study enough to know this basic behavior of diffusers, and it might not be desired for their particular use case. BEWARE!
4. Lack of Intelligibility: In certain scenarios, sound diffusers may negatively impact speech intelligibility, particularly if not positioned correctly. 5. Unpredicted absorption: "Object Edge Diffraction" is a phenomenon to which diffusers are no exception. Diffusers tend to dissipate the entire energy of a limited bandwidth due to friction and edge interactions. Apart from that, the dispersion effects in most cases aren't very audible, and 99% of the time not really needed either, and in turn all these diffusers practically do is absorb a narrow band of frequencies (Design frequencies of the diffuser), as the diffused sound is significantly attenuated, and as mentioned earlier- the diffusion effects are not noticeable in most cases. Hence, many Acoustical Consultants/Designers/Engineers bluntly yet fairly call the diffusers essentially "narrow band absorbers" and find them to be a waste of money, time, material, and effort in most cases, especially in small rooms and DIY constructions.
6. Distance limitations: To be able to effectively observe the diffused field generated by the diffusers, you need to be at a certain distance away from them. As a rule of thumb, for every inch of diffuser depth, move your listening position/microphone at least a foot away. For a typical bedroom mixing studio, that sums up to having a maximum 4" deep diffuser to be on the safer side, hence bringing a diffused range down to somewhere 1200Hz? I don't see where anyone would go with such limited/insignificant diffusion for such a high price!
Installing sound diffusers requires expertise in acoustic design and precise positioning. A DIY approach can lead to misplacement, inadequate or over-diffusion, and compromised room acoustics.
Hiring a professional consultant/designer/builder can be costly, but it is essential to achieve the desired acoustic outcomes. If you're still tempted to build a diffuser yourself; to avoid expensive mistakes, beginners can start with basic diffuser types like Binary Amplitude Diffusers (BAD) or one-dimensional diffusers that offer easier implementation and good diffusion characteristics in a small room.
Conclusion:
Sound diffusers are powerful tools for enhancing room acoustics and creating optimal audio environments. Understanding the working principles, types, dimensional performances, and limitations of diffusers is crucial for making informed decisions during the design and installation process. While exploring sound diffusers can be fascinating, it is essential to engage qualified acoustic consultants for complex installations to avoid costly errors and maximize the potential benefits of these devices. Happy learning! Part 2 coming soon....
留言